← All news
Analysis

Should Ferrari Set Consequences for Hamilton and Leclerc?

Sky Sports F1 analyst Bernie Collins argues that Ferrari should set rules of engagement, with a penalty for breaking them, after the Hamilton–Leclerc clash in Mexico. Rosberg, Chandhok and Brundle also gave their views.

· 2 min read
AI illustration

Collins Calls for Consequences

Sky Sports F1 analyst and former F1 strategist Bernie Collins says Ferrari should define clear rules of engagement for Lewis Hamilton and Charles Leclerc after their clash in Mexico. Hamilton called for "serious talks" after Leclerc tried to pass him at Turn 4 on the opening lap. While the two Ferraris fought, Max Verstappen took advantage and went on to win the Mexico City Grand Prix.

Hamilton and Leclerc have both spoken with team principal Frédéric Vasseur ahead of the Sao Paulo Grand Prix. The content of those conversations will not be revealed until the drivers face the media in Brazil on Thursday.

Collins said the incident is not a huge problem for Ferrari but that the team needs a plan going forward, after Hamilton confirmed there are no rules of engagement at the team when it comes to racing a team-mate. In her view, the drivers can sit down, talk it through and reach a mutual agreement, but there must be a penalty if they break it. A gentleman's agreement with no repercussions would not be enough, she said. Collins pointed to McLaren as an example: a driver who breaks the rules of engagement loses their qualifying preference the following week, a penalty that is not especially harsh but acts as a deterrent.

Vasseur and Rosberg

Vasseur suggested that not enough respect was shown in his drivers' battle, but did not blame either Hamilton or Leclerc. 2016 world champion Nico Rosberg said Vasseur needs to make clear what is acceptable and what is not. According to Rosberg, things can quickly get worse when drivers disregard what has been discussed and sort it out on track themselves.

Earlier Flashpoints

Hamilton and Leclerc have often found themselves fighting since becoming team-mates at the start of 2025, particularly this season as their pace has been evenly matched. They had a race-long fight at the Chinese Grand Prix with brief tyre-to-tyre contact, which Hamilton described as some of the best racing he has experienced in F1.

At Monza in September, Ferrari's home race, the pair went side by side into the first chicane and Hamilton ended up in the gravel on the exit after Leclerc left little room on the outside. Hamilton asked for clearer rules of engagement like those he had at Mercedes, and Leclerc admitted at the next race that he did not behave the way he should have.

By Sky's assessment, the Mexico battle is the biggest incident so far, as it almost certainly cost Ferrari a win or even a one-two.

Chandhok and Brundle

Sky Sports F1's Karun Chandhok said adrenaline is extremely high in a race, especially on the opening lap, with heart rates in the 170s and drivers sometimes acting on natural racing instincts. In his view Leclerc probably needs a calmer approach when racing his team-mate, which may not come naturally to him, so the team may have to push him to think that way.

Martin Brundle believes further flashpoints are inevitable because of the racing driver mentality. Drivers are measured and rewarded as individuals while working within a team, he said, and when a gap opens up and adrenaline is high they will go for it. He compared the situation to Lando Norris running into Oscar Piastri in the Singapore Sprint, saying such incidents do not look good for the team. Ferrari will have to manage it somehow, Brundle added, predicting that in Brazil they will say they have sat down and understood everything, even though in reality it can happen again.

Tags

  • Ferrari
  • Lewis Hamilton
  • Charles Leclerc
  • Frédéric Vasseur
  • Sao Paulo GP
  • Team-mate Rivalry
  • Bernie Collins

Share

Follow us