Retaining Liam Lawson Isn't Enough – Red Bull Must Stop Treating Him Like A Failure
Motorsport.com columnist Oleg Karpov argues that Red Bull retaining Lawson for 2027 is logical, but the real change would be to stop treating young drivers like "goods with an expiry date". Lawson is having a historic season at Racing Bulls.
According to Motorsport.com columnist Oleg Karpov, Liam Lawson never failed at Red Bull Racing in 2025: it was Red Bull that failed Liam Lawson.
In Karpov's opinion piece, the decision to retain Lawson for 2027 is not just logical, but perhaps the first sign that the organisation is changing the habits it developed under Helmut Marko. But the author argues there is one more step Red Bull needs to take to avoid failing Lawson again: it needs to stop treating its young drivers, Lawson included, like goods with an expiry date.
The season in numbers. Karpov says hardly anyone would disagree that the New Zealander deserved to stay in F1 after his performances this year, and that he earned that right under the pressure of having no clarity over his future for so long. Many would probably have cracked or become frustrated, he writes, but Red Bull trained him well in how to shield himself from that pressure and not let it affect his performance.
His strongest spell of the year coincided with a period when the paddock was increasingly asking the same question, more and more loudly: what else does this guy have to do to secure his future?
The final confirmation came after a run of five races in the points, four of which he finished seventh, putting him in a class of his own in the midfield. That run also included some stunning qualifying performances and bold moves on track. He is ninth in the standings, with more than double the points of Pierre Gasly, who occupies the next position. It is largely thanks to Lawson's contribution that Racing Bulls now looks set to secure its best result in the team's history.
The shadow of 2025. Karpov writes that 2026 is surely Lawson's strongest season to date, at least in F1, and also the first in which he has been able to prove what he is capable of without being called up as a stand-in or rushed into an impossible task, as happened in early 2025. His dreadful couple of races for Red Bull did not come as a surprise to anyone, apart, seemingly, from the organisation itself. Expecting him to deliver something substantially better after being placed in the same garage as Max Verstappen after just 11 F1 starts was, the author says, like expecting a newly graduated medical student to perform open-heart surgery on his second day on the job.
Those two races remain a somewhat defining part of how Lawson is perceived today, and perhaps one of the reasons why it took so long to confirm his future. The idea that he had his chance and failed still seems to dominate some people's assessment of him, both outside and within Red Bull.
The author adds that Lawson's F1 career to date has been incredibly fragmented despite him never changing employers: two short spells with the Faenza team, then the rush into Red Bull, followed by his demotion. Even this year, the first in which he is about to finish the season with the team he started pre-season testing with, he was called up for three races to stand in for Isack Hadjar. This year's VCARB 03 is the first car he can truly call his own in Formula 1, having worked on its development last year and tested it properly ahead of the championship. He is still just 24.
The Marko era and the "expiry date". According to Karpov, the decision to deny Nikola Tsolov a place in order to retain Lawson is not just an indication of how highly Red Bull rates the New Zealander's season, but also perhaps a sign that the organisation is beginning to move away from Marko's uncompromising approach and his tendency towards sudden, dramatic decisions. There is no denying that the Austrian built something incredibly successful with his junior programme, he writes, and even on the current grid there are plenty of former Red Bull juniors brought into F1 by Marko. But it is also true that some drivers never reached their full potential under that system.
The author names Jean-Eric Vergne, Sebastien Buemi and even Daniil Kvyat as drivers who potentially had more to offer had they not been overlooked, shown the door or promoted too early. He details the Vergne case: the Frenchman was not retained by Toro Rosso after three seasons at the end of 2014 and did not get his promotion to Red Bull when Vettel left for Ferrari. Marko rushed Kvyat into the senior team instead, despite Vergne comfortably outscoring the Russian in their single season together. Vergne never found another seat in F1. Kvyat lost his Red Bull drive just over a year after being promoted. In Karpov's view, Kvyat was in the same position as the inexperienced firefighter Lawson would find himself in a decade later.
His verdict: it was not Lawson who failed a year and a half ago, but a system in which everyone was judged by the same yardstick, "if you're as good as Verstappen, you'll survive". But not everyone is, not only in terms of absolute talent but also in the way they develop. Generational talents are generational talents precisely because they are rare.
Karpov also says talk of Lawson having world championship potential is typical F1: when someone impresses there is always such talk, but it is about as meaningful as writing someone off completely after two races. He expects Lawson's 2027 to begin against a backdrop of speculation that it could be his final year in F1, because over the years under Marko Red Bull has conditioned us to believe that its young drivers have an expiry date.
The author asks: is that really the right approach? That may be a question Red Bull needs to answer for itself. If retaining Lawson really signals a change, he argues, the organisation should make clearer that things will be different from now on: that a driver who is performing should not have to fear being shown the door simply because he has become too experienced. World