← All news
Analysis

How Good Is Hamilton And How Long Can He Stay In F1? Q&A

BBC F1 correspondent Andrew Benson answered reader questions: how good is Hamilton at his 400th race and how long can he last, why "yo-yo racing" has reduced, why Ocon wants to stay in F1 as a reserve, why Lawson has not been confirmed for 2027, and how F1 should preserve classic circuits.

· 6 min read
AI illustration

After Lando Norris won the Sao Paulo Grand Prix, BBC F1 correspondent Andrew Benson answered readers' questions. The race was run in wet-dry-wet conditions, with Verstappen starting from the back and finishing second and Hadjar third. Mercedes clinched the constructors' championship for the first time since 2021. Highlights of the Q&A follow.

How good is Hamilton and how long can he last? Hamilton has completed his 400th Grand Prix with more than 100 poles. One reader noted that some drivers have a better pole percentage and asked how good he is and how long he can stay at the top.

Benson wrote that Hamilton is unquestionably one of the greatest F1 drivers in history. Statistically he is the most successful, with the most wins and poles, tied with Michael Schumacher on seven championships, and many argue he should have eight given the controversy of the mishandled final race of the 2021 season. Greatness is about more than raw statistics, he wrote, and Hamilton has consistently been at the very highest level, with drives such as the 2008 British GP and the 2021 Brazilian GP going down in history.

Hamilton has won races in all his seasons except 2022, 2023 and 2025. According to Benson, Hamilton struggled relatively, within the context of his career, in the "ground-effect" era of 2022-25. He was beaten by Mercedes team-mate George Russell in two of their three seasons together and looked a shadow of his usual self against Leclerc in 2025. Those performances led some to question why a driver famed for adaptability did not seem able to adapt to the driving style required, which led to questions about his age. Now 41, Hamilton is back in much more familiar territory with this year's cars, performing extremely well again and neck-and-neck with Leclerc.

Hamilton is sensitive to such questions. Last weekend in Brazil, when his 400th race came up, he said he never thought he would reach numbers like that, that he still feels young, and that regardless of what people say, as last week's pole showed, he still has the pace, the speed and the dedication and focus. Benson wrote that on the age front there is no obvious reason why Hamilton cannot continue for a good few more years, pointing out that 45-year-old Fernando Alonso is still performing at an extremely high level, as he proved again in Brazil. Hamilton has said he wants to race at least until F1 returns to Africa, which will not be until 2030 at the earliest, when he will also be 45. For that he will need at least one new contract, as his current one with Ferrari is believed to end next year.

Why has "yo-yo racing" reduced? "Yo-yo racing" was a term coined at the start of this year for a new character of on-track battle in which cars swapped positions multiple times over a series of laps. According to Benson this was caused by the new power units, a near 50-50 split between internal combustion and electrical power that are fundamentally energy starved. The engines have "overtake" and "boost" modes. "Boost" lets a driver demand extra electrical energy whenever he wants, as long as the battery has charge. "Overtake" mode gives a driver following within one second of a car in front an extra 0.5MJ of energy recovery and deployment per lap.

At the start of the season, combined with the teams' and drivers' relative unfamiliarity with the new technology, one driver would have more electrical energy and use it to overtake, whereupon the driver behind would now have more and overtake back. It has been less prevalent recently for two reasons, Benson writes. First, the tracks in recent weeks have been less "energy-starved". Second, drivers and teams have now used the engines for a season and are much more on top of how to use them and how not to leave themselves vulnerable. In addition, rule changes have been introduced since the start of the season to reduce the impact of energy starvation, such as imposing energy limits on tracks where it is a major issue.

Into next year and beyond, further steps are being taken to make the engines more "normal" by changing the energy split to 60-40 in two steps by 2028. Benson says this will almost certainly reduce the frequency of overtaking while drivers become happier with how the cars feel to drive. Whether the audience perceives that as better or worse racing remains to be seen.

Why would Ocon want to stay in F1 as a reserve? A reader asked why Ocon would want to stay in F1 as a reserve rather than race elsewhere. When it became clear that Ocon would not be retained by Haas next year and his options for a race seat had evaporated, Benson wrote, the Frenchman was insistent his F1 career was not over. Staying involved as a reserve, if he can find a spot, is the best way to keep current. A reserve is available should either of the race drivers be incapacitated, stays familiar with current F1 machinery through simulator sessions and perhaps driving recent cars, and keeps his face in people's minds. Race elsewhere, whether in IndyCar, Formula E or endurance racing, and it is much easier to be forgotten, or for people to assume your time has come and gone.

Why has Lawson not been confirmed for 2027? Benson wrote that the decision on which two of the three drivers in contention will drive for Racing Bulls is in the hands of the Red Bull shareholders Chalerm Yoovidhya and Mark Mateschitz and Red Bull's ultimate F1 boss Oliver Mintzlaff. Lawson is in contention along with team-mate Arvid Lindblad and F2 front-runner Nikola Tsolov.

The old Red Bull way under Helmut Marko and Christian Horner would have been to jettison Lawson now, since he has had his chance in the lead team, and put in Tsolov. The counter-argument is that leaves two unproven talents going against each other next year, so Red Bull would not know what they are looking at. On this view, it is better to keep Lawson and Lindblad together next year to get a fuller reading on Lindblad, with Lawson as a known-quantity benchmark, then drop whoever performs least well at the end of 2027 in favour of Tsolov. Racing Bulls team boss Alan Permane made this second argument in not so many words in Brazil. Red Bull has had a very successful young driver programme, he said, and he does not want to be critical, but if critics think drivers perhaps have not had enough time to settle or snap decisions have been made, "we're trying to apply a little bit of science, and that takes some time." Time is on their side, he said, they are not in a rush, he is very confident the right decision will be made and realises it is frustrating for the drivers, but they want to get it right.

Should F1 do more to preserve classic circuits? A reader noted that Interlagos consistently produces thrilling races. Benson wrote that F1 faces a difficult balancing act: it wants a truly global world championship, exciting racing, a good mix of circuit types and to make money. That is not always an easy equation to solve for classic tracks, which are often in countries not able or willing to pay big fees, unlike autocracies that want to use races for national self-promotion.

F1 is well aware of the importance of classic circuits and wants to keep the best of them, so it makes compromises that keep the likes of Monaco, Silverstone, Spa and Suzuka on the calendar, even if Spa is no longer there every year. At the same time it makes a considerable effort to make new tracks as interesting as possible. Las Vegas, for example, is far from the greatest track in terms of driving challenge, made up as it is of streets in an American city, but makes up for it with spectacle and kudos. Of forthcoming permanent circuits, former F1 driver Alex Wurz, the designer of the new tracks in Qiddiyah, Saudi Arabia, and Rwanda, has done his level best to make them fulfilling and challenging.

Formula 1 continues with the Las Vegas GP (20-22 November).

Tags

  • Lewis Hamilton
  • 400th race
  • yo-yo racing
  • power unit
  • Esteban Ocon
  • reserve driver
  • Liam Lawson
  • Racing Bulls
  • Nikola Tsolov
  • classic circuits
  • Interlagos
  • Andrew Benson

Share

Follow us